Hit or miss

[The Minish Link 1]

My first idea: A 3D Paper Mario, without the "Paper" Title.

Hit? Or miss? Meaning: Good idea, or Total flop?

[Max 10]

so basicly, you mean just a mario game. what about it being like mario64 but for the wii.

[The Minish Link 1]

Well, no, I mean ANY game, just this is my first idea.

But your idea is better, but what it needs is THIS:

Fire suit

Frog Suit

Cape

Ice Mario (Walks on water and shoots ice balls that freeze people)

Invincibility star,

And there would be TWO versions: Number 1 is for Wii and is developed by Nintendo. Number 2 is for DS and is developed by Intelligent Systems and is a 3D platfomer.

[Goron Merchant 1]

I think that that just sounds like an ordinary Mario game.

I like Paper Mario.

[The Minish Link 1]

So you think a 3D Paper Mario without the paper title would ruin it?

[LDGM 0]

So you think a 3D Paper Mario without the paper title would ruin it?

*slogan*

it's paper mario without the paper!

[Gingerlink 2]

yeah that's just stupid, you're really making a lot of threads today aren't you?

Ok, how about this, a game where you play as a sort of mage where you use basic attacks and skills of 4 types, fire, ice, lighning and nature. It's a first or third person game played similarly to zelda, solving puzzles using the various magical techniques and there would also be an online mode, which would end up similar to halo. The skills would include things like ice shards, fireballs, camoflage, disguises, ice shields, controling things and electrocution.

[Umbreon 0]

yeah that's just stupid, you're really making a lot of threads today aren't you?

Ok, how about this, a game where you play as a sort of mage where you use basic attacks and skills of 4 types, fire, ice, lighning and nature. It's a first or third person game played similarly to zelda, solving puzzles using the various magical techniques and there would also be an online mode, which would end up similar to halo. The skills would include things like ice shards, fireballs, camoflage, disguises, ice shields, controling things and electrocution.

sounds fun

[Gingerlink 2]

note to self, create game company before idea is stolen.

[Max 10]

yeah, i'd play. it would be like halo/oblivian/zelda.

[The Minish Link 1]

New idea: (by me)

Landstalker remake. In 3D. For the Wii. Is mostly third person, except for enemy encounters, which requires a lot of strategy and dodging and whatnot. The First person encounters play like Red Steel. Think Red Steel meets Zelda, without any Guns.